Will Your Tax Returns Understate The True Value of Your Auto Service Business? -

Will Your Tax Returns Understate The True Value of Your Auto Service Business?

After more than 30 years of owning and successfully running the town’s well-known and successful auto service business…starting out long ago as a single location and growing to multiple sites over the course of his career…Dan the Auto Man is about to make the biggest decision of his professional life.

buttonDan has decided that it’s time to find a buyer for his aftermarket business. He looked ahead a few years ago and planned to sell at an unspecified date in the future. Now is that time. For years, as his family grew and matured and became involved in the business, he had assumed one or more of his children would carry on the legacy of the firm. But, as adults, they have now clearly told their ­father that the 60-hour workweeks and personal sacrifices they witnessed Dan ­experiencing for so many years, along with all the inherent risks in running a family business, do not interest them.

Dan’s fallback had been to sell to trusted long-term ­employees and retire on the note payments and rents that he would receive out of the future earnings of the business. But after taking a long, hard look, Dan ­realized that as skilled as his employees are, the downside risks of his financial security being dependent on his ­employees are too great. He was not sure he could sleep well at night, worrying about whether or not they could run the business as well as he has and provide for his comfortable retirement in the process.

So, the optimal option, Dan has ­determined, is to find a buyer who can grow and expand his legacy while also receiving a cash settlement that he could safely ­invest for his ­retirement.

That being the case, there is one particularly significant task that must be done to prepare for successfully selling at a price that will justify the years of hard work Dan put into his business.

Recasting: Because a Buyer is Buying His Future, Not Your Past

One of the biggest mistakes a seller can make is simply providing a buyer copies of the business tax returns or unadjusted financial statements. The objective of most owners and their accountants is to do everything that they can to minimize taxable income. This is effective for reducing taxes, but it paints an incomplete picture when it comes to showing a potential buyer the true cash flow, and hence the maximum value, of the business. If you want buyers to get excited about your auto service business, they need to truly appreciate the full financial benefit and actual income-generating ability. By “recasting” or adjusting the financial statements for presentation purposes, the “real” financial performance of the business can be demonstrated.

A “recast financial statement” is a reconstructed representation of the earnings that a buyer would be able to enjoy from the business. It “normalizes” the figures by removing all the unusual, non-recurring and one-time items that would not likely occur in the future for the buyer. Recasting supplements the owner’s compensation listed on the tax return with all other “perks” or fringe benefits, while also adding back depreciation, amortization, ­interest payments and capital investments in equipment or property improvements.

thinkRecasting financials before selling a company may raise eyebrows for those that have not heard the term ­before. However, just as a homeowner “stages” their house before putting it on the market, you will want to ­legitimately dress up your business ­financials. You certainly can work to improve its appearance physically, and you also should make the numbers look as attractive as possible. After all, those cash flow numbers will be a crucial element of how buyers will determine the price they are willing to pay for your business and how much money that a bank will be willing to lend to the buyer.

Dan himself was not well versed in the practice of recasting and was not sure what it entails, so he is using the services of a business broker to guide and assist in the process.

Keep in mind one key principle of the selling process: A buyer is buying his future, not your past. The only way to accurately highlight your future profitability is by recasting your historical financials so that the buyer can use these figures to project out three to five years, using the new recast baseline as their starting point. So if your broker does not have an understanding of the automotive service business or does not take the extra time to dig into your financials for all of the appropriate add-backs, your base year could understate your profitability, impacting what buyers will pay for your company.

The person providing the recasting service will ask you lots of questions about your expenses and request supporting documentation to find as many legitimate add-back items as possible. Brokers who have sold dozens of automotive service businesses will have the skills and knowledge to quickly spot expense levels that are above industry norms and search for non-recurring purchases or personal perks that can be added to maximize your cash flow.

Case Study

For example, let’s assume a buyer is looking at two similar auto service companies for sale. Both are generating similar levels of revenue.

Seller A gives the buyer a 2013 tax return showing $50,000 in net income and $75,000 in officer salary. Thus, Seller A is disclosing $125,000 for this year in Seller’s Discretionary Cash Flow.

Seller B has his broker prepare a detailed marketing package including three years of recasted financials documenting $250,000 per year in Seller’s Discretionary Cash Flow.

Which of these sellers do you think will receive a better offer? With this example, you can see how vital ­recasting is in protecting you from ­offers that are too low.

One caveat: My discussion of ­recasting presumes your financials are in good order and expenses are categorized accurately. If not, you need to start there and get your financials cleaned up first. If not, no matter how carefully you document your recasting, your actions could be based on inaccurate financial information.

Recasting Checklist

The most important recasting adjustment is to clearly document the “owners benefit,” including all perks and personal expenses that may be run through the business. Dan worked with his CPA and me utilizing the following checklist to adjust the past income statements (the last three years) for Dan the Auto Man to document all of his benefits of ownership ­beyond the salary shown on the tax return. Every business and situation is different, but in Dan’s case it was ­appropriate to add back the following expenses:

• All health, disability and life insurance premiums and company contributions to his retirement account;

• Dan’s wife’s salary for part time ­administrative work which could be done by a buyer;

• Dan’s teenage son’s wages, since his occasional work cleaning up around the shop was not essential to the business;

• The cost of Dan and his family’s cell phone, personal vehicle and maintenance expenses that were run through the business;

• Parts purchased by the business to fix up Dan’s classic 1965 Ford Mustang convertible;

• Travel and entertainment expenses that were not essential to the business;

• Legal and accounting expenses paid by the business for Dan’s new will and estate planning services;

• Training and seminar expenses for Dan’s networking group; and

• New computers at Dan’s house and his personal laptop

In addition, other recasting actions could include adding back:

• Depreciation and amortization;

• Interest payments on the business bank loan;

• One-time cost of a major write-down in inventory to remove obsolete parts;

• Equipment lease payments since the small remaining balance could be paid off at closing;

• Rent paid to Dan as the owner of the property over and above the amount to be paid by the buyer;

• The purchase of two new lifts, including installation, and a brake lathe that were expensed in full by the business; and

• Charitable donations and certain advertising/sponsorship expenses that would not benefit the business.

You Are Not Trying to Mislead Buyers

Adding transparency and portraying the actual potential of your business will make it more attractive to buyers. To do this, recast financial statements to adjust your income statement to show what would have been real, ­operational cash flow.

Although it may take some time, don’t underestimate the impact recasting financials will have on how your business value is perceived. It’s time well spent when selling a company.

The goal is to make the potential cash flow of your business clear to a buyer, their accountant and their bank.  But be prepared to justify all add-backs with supporting documentation such as invoices and payroll records. Most buyers and their ­accountants will demand a due ­diligence period to verify all claims.

A good broker will orchestrate this process by anticipating the questions and being prepared to quickly ­respond.

Showcase your business as attractively as possible to attract the buyers you have targeted. When it comes to maximizing the sale price, don’t leave money on the closing table by not ­investing in professionally prepared marketing materials and cash flow statements. Your retirement income and peace of mind is dependent on ­recouping all of the value of building a successful ­enterprise.

You May Also Like

Shop Equipment ROI – Tooled for Profit

Understanding how to calculate ROI can help your purchasing decisions.

I’m not a financial scholar by any means, but I know what return on investment (ROI) is. It’s a mathematical formula that yields a representation of the profitability of any type of investment. In the automotive repair industry, we primarily associate this with equipment. Admittedly, I’ve never used the term much, more often approaching things from the standpoint, “Am I making money with this or not?” As technicians and shops, our typical thought process centers on each individual job, how much time and money we have into it, so we’re used to thinking profit or loss, and also pretty good at knowing if we made money, or if we lost our “back quarters.”But over time I’ve learned that the thought process alone is not always the best approach, and making money doesn’t necessarily mean a good ROI. Even if you don’t go crazy with an exponentially long, complicated equation, if you understand the basic idea and process of calculating ROI, it can help you make good purchasing decisions. The base calculation would be dividing your net profits by the cost of the equipment. That’s your ROI. Then, if you want to take it further, you can divide that number to get a time-based ROI average.Let’s look at a basic calculation. You buy something for $10, then sell it for $14. Your profit is $4. Divide profit by investment, ($4/$10) and you get an ROI of 40%. Not bad, but if it took two years to make this profit, then your ROI would be 20% annualized, which is not as impressive. You can use this basic formula to compare products you sell as well, and it may help you decide what’s best to keep in stock or not.Now let’s try something with equipment. You have an old tire machine that’s paid for. You average one set of tires per week and it takes 1.5 hours to complete the job. You decide to buy a new tire machine that is much quicker and more efficient but it cost you $20,000. Now the same job only takes one hour. Based on the cost of technician salary, you calculate that it saves you $30 per job with this new equipment. In this case you would use the formula: savings (additional profit)/investment. At one set of tires per week, that works out to $1,560 per year. $1,560/$20,000 equals an ROI of approximately 8%. That’s not too good. It will take you almost 12 years to pay off the new machine.On the other hand, if you average five sets of tires per week, then your additional profit for the first year is $7,800. $7,800/$20,000 equals an ROI of 39%. That’s pretty good. A general rule of thumb is to pay off any piece of equipment within two to three years. This puts you right on track.But now, here is the problem. This is where we throw the proverbial wrench into the plans. Equipment is tricky. You should also calculate in installation and maintenance costs, as well as the cost of training for the new equipment, and factor in how long the equipment is going to be relevant. This is an especially important factor when considering a scan tool, the required updates and how long before it’s potentially obsolete. In the case of a tire machine, you can also calculate in savings from other benefits of a new machine, such as no more damage to wheels or tire pressure monitoring system (TPMS) sensors, which the new machine can eliminate.Some of this can be overwhelming, and it makes me realize why it’s easier just to fly by the seat of your pants and wonder, “Am I making money or not?” It’s an important business aspect, however, to know what is behind the idea because it can benefit you in so many ways. Even without math, you can almost visualize the numbers in your head.I’ll try it by leaving the formulas out to decide whether it makes sense to buy a dedicated TPMS tool when you already have a full-function scan tool with TPMS ability.If you get a TPMS problem every day and you use your full-function scan tool to diagnose it, most likely it takes much longer to boot and longer to navigate to the function. Even then, it may not cover all you need. Because there’s such a vast amount of information that a full-function scan tool has, it simply takes more for the manufacturer to keep everything current. Plus, you often must still rely on service information for certain procedures and then, if it’s the only scan tool for your shop, it ties it up for use in other diagnostics.Now, let’s compare that to a dedicated TPMS tool. Built with only one function in mind, they can make the process much quicker, have greater coverage, boot quicker and quickly walk you through all steps of any required TPMS resets. When you factor in the savings in time and the fact that your primary scan tool isn’t tied up, you can prove the value of a dedicated TPMS tool through ROI calculations. On the other hand, if you rarely work on TPMS systems, you can prove it wouldn’t make sense at all, since you do have the function on your primary scan tool.While you haven’t done any calculations, you’ve thought of it in that manner and can picture where the calculations might end up. If you’re on the fence, the math will give you the answer. Ultimately, your accountant could take the idea even further, with an undoubtedly more advanced knowledge of ROI, and almost certainly a way to calculate depreciation into the formula. That’s where I sign off, but you get the idea. It’s a great concept that represents fundamental business financials.

Read November’s Digital Edition of ShopOwner

Every issue of ShopOwner includes valuable business management and technical editorial content.

Read Shop Owner’s October Digital Edition Now

Every issue of ShopOwner includes valuable business management and technical editorial content.

Grand Touring Tire Market Adapts To Changing Demands

The days of grand touring tires being fitted only to sedans are a thing of the past.

Catalytic Converter Replacement Rules

Converters must be certified and labeled with the correct codes that are stamped into the shell.

Other Posts

Read September’s Digital Edition of ShopOwner

Every issue of ShopOwner includes valuable business management and technical editorial content.

Circling The World Of Digital Finance

Digitalization affects banks and financial institutions, but also businesses (like yours) that rely on them.

Read The August Issue Of ShopOwner Now

Every issue of ShopOwner includes valuable business management and technical editorial content.

Read Your July Issue of ShopOwner Online Now

Every issue of ShopOwner includes valuable business management and technical editorial content.